A Chaotic Tours of the ‘Halls’ of the Logoi of the Herodotus ‘Muses’: Review of the English Historiography on the ‘Father of History’ and His Work in the New Guide-Book

  • Aleksandr Sinitsyn The Russian Christian Academy for the Humanities St. Petersburg, Rosja
  • Igor Surikov Institute of World History Russian Academy of Sciences Moscow, Rosja


Allison J.W. 1989. Power and Preparedness in Thucydides. Baltimore.

Allison J.W. 2013. The Balance of Power and Compositional Balance: Thucydides Book 1. In: A. Tsakmakis, M. Tamiolaki (eds.), Thucydides between History and Literature. Berlin; Boston, 257-270.

Anhalt E.K. 1993. Solon the Singer: Politics and Poetics. Lanham.

Asheri D., Lloyd A., Corcella A. 2007. A Commentary on Herodotus Books I-IV. O. Murray and A. Moreno (eds.), with a contribution of M. Brosius. Oxford.

Austin N. 2008. Helen of Troy and Her Shameless Phantom. Ithaca; London (11994).

Bakker E.J. 2002. The Making of History: Herodotus’ Historiēs Apodexis. In: E.J. Bakker, I.J.F. de Jong, H. van Wees (eds.), Brill’s Companion to Herodotus. Leiden; Boston; Köln, 3-32.

Bakker M. de. 2012. Herodotus’ Proteus: Myth, History, Enquiry and Storytelling. In: E. Baragwanath, M. de Bakker (eds.), Myth, Truth, and Narrative in Herodotus. Oxford, 107-126.

Baragwanath E. 2012. Returning to Troy: Herodotus and the Mythic Discourse of his own Time. In: E. Baragwanath, M. de Bakker (eds.), Myth, Truth, and Narrative in Herodotus. Oxford, 287-312.

Beck I. 1971. Die Ringkomposition bei Herodot und ihre Bedeutung für die Beweistechnik. Hildesheim; New York.

Beck D. 2014. Simile Structure in Homeric Epic and Vergil’s Aeneid. In: R. Scodel (ed.), Between Orality and Literacy: Communication and Adaptation in Antiquity. Leiden; Boston, 244-266.

Bichler R. 2001. Herodots Welt: Der Aufbau der Historie am Bild der fremden Länder und Völker, ihrer Zivilisation und ihrer Geschichte. Berlin.

Boedeker D. 2002. Epic Heritage and Mythical Patterns in Herodotus. In: E.J. Bakker, I.J.F. de Jong, and H. van Wees (eds.), Brill’s Companion to Herodotus. Leiden; Köln: Brill, 97-116.

Bouzarovski S., Barker E. 2016. Between East and West: Movements and Transformations in Herodotean Topology. In: E. Barker, S. Bouzarovski, Ch. Pelling, L. Isaken (eds.), New Worlds from Old Texts. Oxford, 155-179.

Bowie A.M. 1993. Homer, Herodotus, and the ‘Beginnings’ of Thucydides’ History. In: H.D. Jocelyn (ed.), Tria Lustra: Essays and Notes presented to John Pinsent. Liverpool, 141-147.

Bowie A. 2018. Herodotus the Story-Teller. In: E. Bowie (ed.), Herodotus - Narrator, Scientist, Historian. Berlin; Boston, 25-36.

Bowie E. (ed.) 2018. Herodotus - Narrator, Scientist, Historian. Berlin; Boston.

Cartledge P. 1993. The Greeks: A Portrait of Self and Others. Oxford.

Cobet J. 2002. The Organization of Time in the Histories. In: E.J. Bakker, I.J.F. de Jong, H. van Wees (eds.), Brill’s Companion to Herodotus. Leiden; Boston; Köln, 387-412.

Connor W.R. 1984. Thucydides. Princeton, NJ.

Dovatur A.I. 1957. Povestvovatel’nyy i nauchnyy stil’ Gerodota [Narrative and scientific style of Herodotus]. Leningrad (in Russian). Доватур, А. И. Повествовательный и науч- ный стиль Геродота. Л.

Douglas M. 2007. Thinking in Circles: An Essay on Ring Composition. New Haven; London.

Ellis J.R. 1991. The Structure and Argument of Thucydides’ Archaeology. ClAnt 10/2, 344-375.

Ellis J.R. 1994. Thucydidean Method in the Kylon, Pausanias and Themistokles Logoi. Arethusa 27/2, 165-191.

Engels J. 2007. Ringkomposition. In: G. Ueding (hrsg.). Historisches Wörterbuch der Rhetorik. Bd. 8: Rhet-St. Tübingen, 241-246.

Fehling D. 1989. Herodotus and his ‘Sources’: Citation, Invention, and Narrative Art. Trans. By J.G. Howie. Leeds (= Die Quellenangaben bei Herodot. Studien zur Erzählkunst Herodots. Berlin, 1971).

Fialho M. do C. 2020: Ethnicity in Herodotus: the story of Helen through the Egyptians’ eyes. In: Th.

Figueira, C. Soares (eds.), Ethnicity and Identity in Herodotus. London; New York, 258-268.

Figueira Th., Soares C. (eds.) 2020. Ethnicity and Identity in Herodotus. London; New York.

Finkelberg M. 1995. Sophocles’ Tr. 634-639 and Herodotus. Mnemosyne 48/2, 146-152.

Fornara C.W. 1971. Herodotus: An Interpretative Essay. Oxford.

Foster E., Lateiner D. (eds.) 2012. Thucydides and Herodotus. Oxford.

Fowler R.L. 2007. Early Greek Mythography. I. Texts. Oxford.

Fowler R.L. 2013. Early Greek Mythography. II. Commentary. Oxford.

Gasparov M.L. 1989. Nepolnota i simmetrija v “Istorii” Gerodota [Incompleteness and symmetry in Herodotus’ “History”]. VDI 2 (189), 117-122 (in Russian). Гаспаров М.Л. 1989. Неполнота и симме-трия в «Истории» Геродота. Вестник древ- ней истории 2 (189), 117-122.

Gasparov M.L. 1997. Izbrannye trudy. T. 1: O poetakh [Selected works. Vol. 1: On poets]. Moscow (in Russian). Гаспаров, М.Л. 1997: Избранные труды. Т. 1: О поэтах. М.

Griffin J. 2006. Herodotus and Tragedy. In: C. Dewald, J. Marincola (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Herodotus. Cambridge, 46-59.

Grintser N.P. 2016. Gerodot kak literaturnyi kritik [Herodotus as a literary critic]. SHAGI/Steps

/2-3, 95-118 (in Russian). Гринцер Н.П. 2016. Геродот как литератур- ный критик. ШАГИ/Steps 2/2-3, 95-118.

Grintser N.P. 2018. Herodotus as a literary critic. In: E. Bowie (ed.), Herodotus - Narrator, Scientist, Historian. Berlin; Boston, 157-174.

Hammond N.G.L. 1952. The Arrangement of the Thought in the Proem and in Other Parts of Thucydides I. CQ, n.s. 2, 127-141.

Hart J. 1982. Herodotus and Greek History. London.

Hartog F. 1980. Le miroir d’Hérodote: Essai sur la représentation de l’autre. Paris.

Hartog F. 1999. Pervye istoriki Gretsii: istorichnost’ i istorija [The first historians of Greece: historicity and history]. VDI 1 (228), 177-187 (in Russian).

Артог Ф. 1999. Первые историки Греции: историчность и история. Вестник древней истории 1 (228), 177-187.

Herodotus 1922. Herodotus [Histories]. With an English trans. by A.D. Godley. In 4 vols. Vol. 3: Books V-VII. London; New York.

How W.W., Wells J. 1912. A Commentary on Herodotus with Introduction and Appendixes. Vol. 1-2. Oxford.

Immerwahr H.R. 1966. Form and Thought in Herodotus. Cleveland.

Irwin E. 2005. Solon and Early Greek Poetry: The Politics of Exhortation. Cambridge.

Jacoby F. 1913. Herodotos. RE Suppl. 2, 205-520.

Jacoby F. 1995. Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (F Gr Hist). Teil. 1: Genealogie und Mythographie. A. Vorrede, Text, Addenda, Konkordanz. Leiden; New York; Köln.

Johnson W.A. 1994. Oral Performance and the Composition of Herodotus’ Histories. GRBS 35, 229-254.

Jong I.J.F. de. 2004. Herodotus. In: I.J.F. de Jong, R. Nünlist, A. M. Bowie (eds.), Narrators, Narratees, and Narrative in Ancient Greek Literature. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 101-114.

Katičić R. 1957. Die Ringkomposition im ersten Buche des thukydideischen Geschichtswerkes. WS 70, 179-196.

Lang M. L. 2011. Thucydidean Narrative and Discourse. J. S. Rusten, R. Hamilton (eds.). Ann Arbor.

Leão D.F. 2020. Barbarians, Greekness, and wisdom: The afterlife of Croesus’ debate with Solon. In: Th. Figueira, C. Soares (eds.), Ethnicity and Identity in Herodotus. London; New York, 271-295.

Liotsakis V. 2017. Redeeming Thucydides’ Book VIII. Narrative Artistry in the Account of the Ionian War. Berlin; Boston.

Lloyd A.B. 1975. Herodotus. Book II. Introduction. Leiden.

Lloyd A.B. 1976. Herodotus. Book II. Commentary 1-98. Leiden.

Lloyd A.B. 1988. Herodotus. Book II. Commentary 99-182. Leiden; New York; København; Köln.

Lohmann D. 1970. Die Komposition der Reden in der Ilias. Berlin.

Lurie S.Ya. 1947. Gerodot [Herodotus]. Moscow; Leningrad (in Russian). Лурье С.Я. 1947. Геродот. М.; Л.

Macan R.W. 1895. Herodotus. The Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Books. With Introduction, Notes, Appendices, Indices, Maps. I. 1: Introduction, Text with Notes. R.W. Macan (ed.). London; New York.

Macan R.W. 1908a. Herodotus. The Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth Books. With Introduction, Text, Apparatus, Commentary, Appendices, Indices, Maps. I. 1: Introduction, Book VII (Text and Commentaries). R.W. Macan (ed.). London.

Macan R.W. 1908b. Herodotus. The Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth Books. With Introduction, Text, Apparatus, Commentary, Appendices, Indices, Maps. I. 2: Books VIII and IX (Text and Commentaries). R.W. Macan (ed.). London.

Marincola J. 2018. Ὁμηρικώτατος? Battle Narratives in Herodotus. In: E. Bowie (ed.), Herodotus - Narrator, Scientist, Historian. Berlin; Boston, 3-24.

McKeon K.P.J. 2020. Barbarians at the Gate: Herodotus, Bisotun, and a Persian Punishment in Egypt. AJPh 141/3, 349-380.

Miller T.A. 1984. Grecheskaja epicheskaja istoriografija [The Greek Epic Historiography]. In: M.L. Gasparov (ed.), Kuznetsova, T.I., Miller, T.A. Antichnaja epicheskaja istoriografija: Gerodot. Tit Livij [The Ancient Epic Historiography: Herodotus. Titus Livius]. Moscow, 6-79 (in Russian).

Миллер Т.А. 1984. Греческая эпическая историография. В кн.: М.Л. Гаспаров (ред.), Кузнецова, Т.И., Миллер, Т.А. Античная эпическая историография: Геродот. Тит Ливий. М., 6-79.

Minchin E. 1995. Ring-Patterns and Ring-Composition: Some Observations on the Framing of Stories in Homer. Helios 22/1, 23-35.

Minchin E. 2007. Homeric Voices: Discourse, Memory, Gender. Oxford.

Momigliano A. 1966. Studies in Historiography. New York.

Momigliano A. 1977. Essays in Ancient and Modern Historiography. Oxford.

Munson R.V. 2001. Ananke in Herodotus. JHS 121, 30-50.

Myres J.L. 1953. Herodotus Father of History. Oxford.

Nikolaidou-Arabatzi S. 2018. ἱστορέειν and θωμάζειν: scientific terms and signs of unity in Herodotus’ ‘Histories’. In: E. Bowie (ed.), Herodotus - Narrator, Scientist, Historian. Berlin; Boston, 223-241.

Nimis S.A. 1999. Ring-Composition and Linearity in Homer. In: E.A. Mackay (ed.), Signs of Orality: The Oral Tradition and its Influence in the Greek and Roman World. Leiden; Boston; Köln, 65-78.

Pearson L. 1975. Early Ionian Historians. Westport, СТ (Oxford, 11939).

Pelling C. 2006. Educating Croesus: Talking and Learning in Herodotus’ Lydian ‘Logos’. ClAnt 25/1, 141-177.

Person R.E., Jr. 2016: From grammar in everyday conversation to special grammar in oral traditions: A case study of ring composition. In: M. Antović, C.P. Cánovas (eds.), Oral Poetics and Cognitive Science. Berlin; München; Boston, 30-51.

Powell J.E. 1939. The History of Herodotus. Cambridge.

Powell J.E. 1949. Herodotus [The Histories]. Trans. by J.E. Powell. Vols. 1-2. Oxford.

Powell J.E. 1966. A Lexicon to Herodotus. Hildesheim (Cambridge, 11938).

Priestley J. 2014. Herodotus and Hellenistic Culture: Literary Studies in the Reception of the Histories. Oxford.

Rawlings H.R. III. 2017. Writing History Implicitly through Refined Structuring. In: R.K. Balot, S. Forsdyke, E. Foster (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Thucydides. Oxford, 195-209.

Ready J.L. 2019. Orality, Textuality, and the Homeric Epics. An Interdisciplinary Study of Oral Texts, Dictated Texts, and Wild Texts. Oxford.

Reece S. 1995. The Three Circuits of the Suitors: A Ring Composition in Odyssey 17-22. Oral Tradition 10/1, 207-229 (URL: https://journal.oraltradition.org/wp-content/uploads/files/articles/10i/13_reece.pdf).

Russell T.J. 2017. Byzantium and the Bosporus. A Historical Study, from the Seventh Century BC until the Foundation of Constantinople. Oxford.

Saïd S. 2002. Herodotus and Tragedy. In: E. J. Bakker, I. J. F. de Jong, H. van Wees (eds.), Brill’s Companion to Herodotus. Leiden; Boston; Köln, 117-145.

Scardino C. 2007. Gestalt und Funktion der Reden bei Herodot und Thukydides. Berlin.

Sinitsyn А.А. 2012. Fronton i final: po powodu ‘zaimstvovanija’ Gerodotom u Fukidida printsipa khronologicheskogo povestvovanija [Pediment and finale: on the ‘borrowing’ of the principle of chronological narration by Herodotus from Thucydides]. Problemy istorii i arkheologii Ukrainy: Materialy VIII mezhdunarodnoj konferentsii (Kharkov, 9-10 nojabrja 2012 g.) [Problems of History and Archeology of Ukraine: Proceedings of the VIII International Conference (Kharkov, 9-10 November 2012). Kharkov, 58 (in Russian).

Синицын А.А. 2012. Фронтон и финал: по поводу «заимствования» Геродотом у Фу-кидида принципа хронологического пове- ствования. Проблемы истории и археологии Украины: Материалы VIII международной конференции (Харьков, 9-10 ноября 2012 г.). Харьков, 58.

Sinitsyn А.А. 2013. Fukidid i Gerodot, povlijavshie drug na druga? (po povodu odnogo ‘interesnogo njuansa’) [Thucydides and Herodotus – had they influenced each other? (as to an ‘interesting nuance’)]. AMA 16, 39-55 (in Russian).

Синицын А.А. 2013. Фукидид и Геродот, по-влиявшие друг на друга? (по поводу одного «интересного нюанса»). Античный мир и археология 16, 39-55.

Sinitsyn А.А. 2015. Greki i monstry: ob antichnoi mifologii kak zanimatel’noi etnogeografii (eskiz na temu puteshestvij i otkrytij) [The Greeks and the Monsters: on classical mythology as an amusing ethnic geography (essay about travels and discoveries]. Bosporskie issledovanija [Bosporus Studies] 31, 186-213 (in Russian).

Синицын А.А. 2015. Греки и монстры: об античной мифологии как занимательной этногеографии (эскиз на тему путешествий и открытий). Боспорские исследования 31, 186-213.

Sinitsyn A.A. 2017a. Gerodot ob izgnanii varvarov iz Evropy i problema zavershennosti pervoi ‘Istorii’ [Herodotus on the Banishment of the Barbarians out of Europe and the Issue of the Completeness of the First ‘History’]. Metamorfozy istorii [Metamorphoses of History] 10, 35-92 (in Russian).

Синицын А.А. 2017a. Геродот об изгнании варваров из Европы и проблема завершен- ности первой «Истории». Метаморфозы истории 10, 35-92.

Sinitsyn A.A. 2017b. Kanaty i mosty Greko-persidskoj voiny [Ropes and Bridges of the Persian War]. In: O.L. Gabelko, E.V. Rung, A.A. Sinitsyn, E.V. Smykov (eds.), Iranica: Iranskie imperii i greko-rimskij mir v VI v. do n.e. – VI v. n.e. [Iranica: Iranian Empires and the Greco- Roman World from the Sixth Century BC to the Sixth Century AD]. Kazan, 137-171 (in Russian).

Синицын А.А. 2017b. Канаты и мосты гре- ко-персидской войны. В кн.: О.Л. Габел- ко, Э.В. Рунг, А.А. Синицын, Е.В. Смыков (ред.), Iranica: Иранские империи и гре- ко-римский мир в VI в до н.э. - VI в н.э. Ка- зань, 137-171.

Sinitsyn A.A. 2017с. ‘Know thyself’ through the dialogue with the Others: Formation of the ancient cultural dichotomy ‘Hellenes–Barbarians’. Judaica Petropolitana 8, 48-82.

Sinitsyn A.A. 2019. τὰ ὅπλα τῶν γεφυρέων of the Persian War: Herodotus on the Banishment of the Barbarians out of Europe and the issue of the Completeness of the First the ‘History’. AAL 65, 83-124.

Sinitsyn A.A., Surikov I.E. 2019. Novyj kollektivnyj trud ob ‘ottse istorii’ kak uchenom i rasskazchike

[A new collective work on the ‘father of history’ as a scholar and narrator]. Mnemon 19/1, 183-216 (in Russian).

Синицын А.А., Суриков И.Е. 2019. Новый коллективный труд об «отце истории» как ученом и рассказчике. Мнемон 19/1, 183- 216.

Skinner J. E. 2012. The Invention of Greek Ethnography: From Homer to Herodotus. Greeks overseas. Oxford.

Stanley K. 1993. The Shield of Homer: Narrative Structure in the Iliad. Princeton.

Stoneman R. 2015. Xerxes: a Persian Life. New Haven; London.

Strauss B. 2005. The Battle of Salamis. The Naval Encounter that Saved Greece - and Western Civilization. New York et al.

Strolonga P. 2015-2016. Structural Symmetry and Parallelism in the Homeric Hymn to Demeter. Αριάδνη 22, 15-44.

Surikov I.E. 1999. Gostepriimstvo Kreza I afinjane [The Hospitality of Croesus and the Athenians]. Zakon i obychaj gostepriimstva v antichnom mire [The Law and Custom of Hospitality in the Ancient World]. Moscow, 72-79 (in Russian).

Суриков И.Е. 1999. Гостеприимство Креза и афиняне. Закон и обычай гостеприимства в античном мире. Доклады конференции. М., 72-79.

Surikov I.E. 2007. ‘Nesvoevremennyj’ Gerodot (epicheskij prosaik mezhdu logographami i Fukididom) [The ‘Inopportune’ Herodotus (An Epic Prosaist between Logographers and__ Thucydides)]. VDI 1 (260), 143-151 (in Russian).

Суриков И.Е. 2007. «Несвоевременный» Геродот (эпический прозаик между лого- графами и Фукидидом). Вестник древней истории 1 (260), 143-151.

Surikov I.E. 2009a. Gerodot [Herodotus]. Moscow (in Russian). Суриков И.Е. 2009. Геродот. М.

Surikov I.E. 2009b. Obrazy vremeni v istoricheskom trude Gerodota [Images of time in Herodotus’ historical work]. AMA 13, 10-35 (in Russian). Суриков И.Е. 2009. Образы времени в исто- рическом труде Геродота. Античный мир и археология 13, 10-35.

Surikov I.E. 2010. Poslednie glavy ‘Istorii’ Gerodota i vopros o stepeni zavershennosti ego truda [The last chapters of Herodotus’ History and the question of the degree of completeness of the work]. In: T.N. Dzhakson, I.G. Konovalova, G.R. Tsetskhladze (eds.), Gaudeamus igitur: sbornik statei k 60-letiiu A.V. Podosinova. Мoscow, 356-363 (in Russian).

Суриков И.Е. 2010. Последние главы «Исто- рии» Геродота и вопрос о степени завершен- ности труда. В кн.: Т.Н. Джаксон, И.Г. Ко- новалова, Г.Р. Цецхладзе (ред.), Gaudeamus igitur: Сб. ст. к 60-летию А.В. Подосинова. М., 356-363.

Surikov I.E. 2011. Ocherki ob istoriopisanii v klassicheskoj Gretsii [Essays on historical writing in Classical Greece]. Moscow (in Russian). Суриков И.Е. 2011. Очерки об историописа- нии в классической Греции. М.

Thomas R. 2000. Herodotus in Context: Ethnography, Science and the Art of Persuasion. Cambridge.

van Rookhuijzen J.Z. 2018. Herodotus and the Topography of Xerxes’ Invasion: Place and Memory in Greece and Anatolia. Berlin; Boston.

Vasilev M.I. 2015. The Policy of Darius and Xerxes towards Thrace and Macedonia. Leiden; Boston.

Vlassopoulos K. 2013. Greeks and Barbarians. Cambridge.

Wells J. 1923. Studies in Herodotus. Oxford.

Welser C. 2009: Two Didactic Strategies at the End of Herodotus’ Histories (9.108-122). ClAnt 28, 359-385.

Whitman C.H. 1958. Homer and the Heroic Tradition. Cambridge.

Wood H. 1972. The Histories of Herodotus: An Analysis the Formal Structure. The Hague; Paris.

Zali V. 2018. Herodotus mapping out his genre: the interaction of myth and geography in the

Libyan logos. In: E. Bowie (ed.), Herodotus - Narrator, Scientist, Historian. Berlin; Boston, 125-138.

Dyskusje i recenzje