Conditions for the development of employee representation in corporate governance in European countries
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26485/SPE/2019/113/17Keywords:
corporate governance, employee representation, corporate governance modelsAbstract
Background: Employee representation in corporate governance bodies already has an established position in European countries. It refers to the two-tier model of governance, with the supervisory board and management board rather than the one-tier model with a board of directors. The development of such representation is influenced by the EU authorities implementing long-term processes to harmonize solutions in member states. Such representation has also been developed in the Nordic countries under the influence of democratization processes. However, in several countries, the processes of limiting such representation can be observed, and this is related to the political conditions (the strengthening of right-wing parties) and a difficult economic situation caused by the 2008 financial crisis.
Research purpose: The purpose of the study is to identify factors that affect changes in the scope of such representation, as well as to determine their effectiveness based on selected case studies.
Methods: In order to achieve the research objective, a critical analysis of the subject literature and appropriate legal regulations was used. The analysis covered, among others, texts published in renowned journals concerning industrial relations (European Journal of Industrial Relations, Industrial Relations Journal), while problems from the legal perspective (Journal of Comparative Law Study) were also analyzed.
Conclusion: It can generally be stated that conditions in recent decades have fostered the development or strengthening of employee representation in corporate governance bodies. The attempts to harmonize employee representation in governance made by the EU authorities should be assessed positively, although their formal results are relatively modest and are limited primarily to the European Company Statute. Positive changes can also be observed in the Nordic countries, where the existing conditions, including primarily the democratization processes, forced the modification of the one-tier model by creating the possibility of including employee representation on the board of directors. At the same time, pressure can be observed in many countries to limit or eliminate employee representation in governance.
References
Council Directive 2001/86/EC of 8 October 2001 supplementing the Statute for a European com¬pany with regard to the involvement of employees.
Draft Act on the rules for exercising certain powers of the Treasury, 2010, http://bip.msp.gov.pl/ portal/bip/115/3516/Projekt_ustawy_o_zasadach_wykonowania_niektórych_uprawnien_ Skarbu_Panstwa.html
Berglund Tom, Holmen Martin, Rana Rakesh, Causes and Consequences of Employee Representation on Corporate Boards, paper presented at the conference, “Twenty Years after Cadbury, Ten Years after Sarbanes-Oxley: Challenges of Corporate Governance”, University of Bath 2013.
Conchon Aline Are employee participation rights under pressure? Trends at national and EU level, European Economic, Employment and Social Policy 2012/7.
Conchon Aline, Board-level employee representation rights in Europe. Facts and Trends, European Trade Union Institute, Report 121, Brussels 2011.
Ekern Steinar, Corporate Governance system in Norwey, Corporate Governance, Winter, 2015/2016.
Enriques Luca, A Harmonized European company law. Are we there already?, International and Comparative Law 2017/66/3.
Fauver Larry, Fuerst Michael E., Does Good Corporate Governance Include Employee Representation? Evidence form German Corporate Boards, Journal of Financial Economics 2006/82.
Gelter Martin, EU company law harmonization between convergence and varieties of capitalism, 2017, https://ssrn.com/abstract-2977500
Giedrowicz-Niewińska Aneta, Udział pracowników w nadzorze korporacyjnym w spółce europejskiej, Institute of Economic Research, Working Paper 2015/33.
Gładoch Monika, Uczestnictwo pracowników w zarządzaniu przedsiębiorstwem w Polsce, Wydawnictwo Dom Organizatora, Toruń 2008
Gold Michael, Taken on board: An evaluation of the influence of employee board level rep¬resentatives on company decision-making across Europe, European Journal of Industrial Relations 2011/15/1.
Gomez Pierre-Yves, Wirtz Peter, Successfully mobilizing for employee board representation: Lessons to be learned from post-war Germany, Journal of Management History 2018/24/3.
Hogedahi Laust, Kongshoj Kristian, New trajectories of unionization in the Nordic Ghent countries: Changing labour market and welfare institutions, European Journal of Industrial Relations 2017/23/4.
Jeżak Jan, Ład korporacyjny. Doświadczenia światowe i kierunki rozwoju, C.H. Beck, Warszawa 2010.
Karta Socjalna Wspólnoty Europejskiej, www.ptps.org.pl/old_siteu_miedzynarodowe.php?ustawodawstwo_id=14, 1989
Kim Han E., Ernst Maug, Christoph Schneider, Labor representation in governance as an insurance mechanism, Review of Finance 2018/22/4.
Kluge Norbert, Vitols Sigurt, The crisis: catalyst for stronger worker participation in corporate governance, 2010, http//www.worker-participation,eu/About-WP/Publications/SEEutope-report
Kolvenbach Walter, Handbook on European Employee Co-management, Kluver Law and Taxation Publisher, Deventer, Boston 1987.
Lekvall Per, The Nordic Corporate Governance Model, SNS Forlag, Stockholm 2014.
Levinson Klas, Employee representatives on company boards in Sweden, Industrial Relations Journal 2001/32.
Mallin Christine A. The Nordic Corporate Governance Model, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2010.
Njoya Wanjiru, Employee Ownership in the European Company: Reflexive Law, Reincorpora¬tion and Escaping Co-determination, Journal of Corporate Law Study 2011/12/2.
O’Kelly Kevin P., Summary Report and Summing up, in: Kevin P. O’Kelly (ed.), The Role of Worker Directors in the European Union, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin 1996.
Roberts John, Steen Eric J. Van den, Human Capital and Corporate Governance, in: Joachim Schwalbach (ed.), Corporate Governance: A Volume in Honor of Horst Albach, Springer Velag, Berlin 2000.
Rudolf Stanisław, Skorupińska Katarzyna, Bezpośrednie formy partycypacji pracowniczej. Polska na tle starych krajów Unii Europejskiej, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego, Łódź 2012.
Rudolf Stanisław, Udział przedstawicieli załogi w organach spółki, in: Dorota Dobija, Izabela Koładkiewicz (red.), Ład korporacyjny. Podręcznik akademicki, Oficyna a Wolters Kluwer business, Warszawa 2011.
Szymańska Agata, Włodarczyk Przemysław, Przedstawicielstwo pracownicze w radzie spółki w krajach członkowskich Unii Europejskiej, Studia Prawno-Ekonomiczne 2012/LXXXVI.
Thomsen Steen, The nordic corporate governance model, Management and Organization Review 2016/12/1.
Workers’ participation at board level in the EU – 15 countries, Reports on the national systems and practices, Hans Bockler Foundation/European Trade Union Institute, Brussels 2004.
Wratny Jerzy, Partycypacja pracownicza. Studium zagadnienia w warunkach transformacji gospodarczej, Instytut Pracy i Spraw Socjalnych, Warszawa 2002.
