Epistemic bandwagons, speculation, and turnkeys. Some lessons from the tale of the urban ‘underclass’
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26485/PS/2023/72.1/1Keywords:
Underclass, Bourdieu, Koselleck, concept formation, epistemic reflexivityAbstract
Drawing on the Begriffsgeschichte of Reinhart Koselleck and the reflexive sociology of Pierre Bourdieu, my book The Invention of the “Underclass” draws a microhistory of the birth, diffusion, and demise of this racialized folk devil at the intersection of the academic field, the journalistic field, and the politics-policy-philanthropic field. This history illuminates the politics of knowledge about dispossessed and dishonored categories in the metropolis and suggests three notions that can help researchers parse the use and abuse of other social science constructs and thus practice better conceptual hygiene: lemming effects (illustrated by the wild rush to deploy “diaspora”), conceptual speculative bubble (as with “racial capitalism”), and turnkey problematics (such as the “resilient city” and the “creative city”). I discuss the factors that foster the development of epistemic bandwagons, speculation, and turnkeys, and specify the criteria that make for a robust concept in terms of semantics (clarity and neutrality), logics (coherence and type-specificity), and heuristics (empirical adequacy and theoretical productivity).
References
Andersson David E., Åke E. Andersson, Charlotta Mellander (eds.). 2011. Handbook of creative cities. London: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Auletta Ken. 1982. The underclass. New York: Vintage (wyd. 2. poprawione: 1999).
Blumer Herbert. 2007 (1954). Jaki błąd tkwi w teorii społecznej? W: tegoż, Interakcjonizm symboliczny. Perspektywa i metoda, 109–118. Kraków: Nomos.
Bourdieu Pierre. 2001. Science de la science et réflexivité. Paris: Raisons d’agir Éditions. (wydanie anglojęzyczne: Science of science and reflexivity, Cambridge: Polity Press, 2004).
Brede Johannes-Maximilian. 2010. Gibt es eine ‘neue städtische Unterklasse’? Armuts- und Ausländerquartiere in Berlin. Münich: Grin Verlag.
Brubaker Rogers. 2005. “The diaspora’s diaspora”. Ethnic and Racial Studies 28(1): 1–19.
Burayidi Michael A., Adriana Allen, John Twigg, Christine Wamsler (eds.). 2019. The Routledge handbook of urban resilience. New York: Routledge.
Burke Kenneth. 1966. Language as symbolic action. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Canguilhem Georges. 1955. La Formation du concept de réflexe aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Paris: Vrin.
Canguilhem Georges. 1981. Idéologie et rationalité dans l’histoire des sciences de la vie. Nouvelles études d’histoire et de philosophie des sciences. Paris: Vrin.
Cohen Stanley. 1972. Folk devils and moral panics: The creation of the mods and rockers. Oxford: Basic Blackwell (wydanie 3: 1987).
Dangschat Jens S. 1994. “Concentration of poverty in the landscapes of «Boomtown» Hamburg: The creation of a new urban underclass?”. Urban Studies 31(7): 1133–1147.
De León Jason. 2015. The land of open graves: Living and dying on the migrant trail. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Faist Thomas. 1993. “From school to work: Public policy and underclass formation among young Turks in Germany during the 1980s”. International Migration Review 27(2): 306–331.
Florida Richard. 2010 (2002). Narodziny klasy kreatywnej oraz jej wpływ na przeobrażenia w charakterze pracy, wypoczynku społeczeństwa i życia codziennego. Warszawa: NCK.
Florida Richard. 2003. “Cities and the creative class”. City and Community 2(1): 3–19.
Florida, Richard. 2012. The new urban crisis: How our cities are increasing inequality, deepening segregation, and failing the middle class – and what we can do about it. New York: Basic Books.
Gerring John. 1999. “What makes a concept good? A criterial framework for understanding concept formation in the social sciences”. Polity 31(3): 357–393.
Go Julian. 2021. “Three tensions in the theory of racial capitalism”. Sociological Theory 39(1): 38–47.
Hatuka Tali, Issachar Rosen-Zvi, Michael Birnhack, Eran Toch, Hadas Zur. 2018. “The political premises of contemporary urban concepts: The global city, the sustainable city, the resilient city, the creative city, and the smart city”. Planning Theory and Practice 19(2): 160–179.
Hauser Richard. 1999. “Tendenzen zur Herausbildung einer Unterklasse?”. In: Deutschland im Wandel. W. Glatzer, I. Ostner (Hrsg.), 133-145. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
Häußermann Hartmut. 1997. “Armut in den Großstädten – eine neue städtische Unterklasse?". Leviathan 25(1): 12–27.
Huysmans Jef. 2008. “The jargon of exception. On Schmitt, Agamben and the absence of political society”. International Political Sociology 2(2): 165–183.
Jencks Christopher, Paul E. Peterson (eds.). 1991. The urban underclass. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution.
Katz Michael B. (red.). 1993. The ‘underclass’ debate: Views from history. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Koselleck Reinhart. 2001. „O historyczno-politycznej semantyce przeciwstawnych pojęć asymetrycznych”. W: tegoż, Semantyka historyczna, 228–284. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Poznańskie.
Koselleck Reinhart. 2009. Dzieje pojęć. Studia z semantyki i pragmatyki języka społeczno-politycznego. Warszawa: Oficyna Naukowa.
Kronauer Martin. 1998. “Armut, Ausgrenzung, Unterklasse”. In: Großstadt: Soziologische Stichworte, H. Häußermann (Hrsg.), 126–146. Wiesbaden: VSA Verlag.
Merton Robert K. 1984. Socio-economic duration: A case study of concept formation in sociology. In: Conflict and consensus: A Festschrift in honor of Lewis A. Coser, W.W. Powell, R. Robbins (eds.), 262–285. New York: Free Press.
Mincy Ronald B. 1994. The underclass: Concept, controversy and evidence. In: Poverty and public policy: What do we know? What should we do?, S.H. Danziger, G.D. Sandefur, D.H. Weinberg (eds), 109–146. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Myrdal Gunnar. 1963. Challenge to affluence. New York: Random House.
Peck Jamie. 2005. “Struggling with the creative class”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 29(4): 740–770.
Phillips Kristin. 2018. An ethnography of hunger: Politics, subsistence, and the unpredictable grace of the sun. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Ralph Michael, Maya Singhal. 2019. “Racial Capitalism”. Theory and Society 48(6): 851–881.
Ricketts Erroll R., Isabel V. Sawhill. 1988. “Defining and measuring the underclass”. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 7(2): 316–325.
Sartori Giovanni. 1970. “Concept misformation in comparative politics”. American Political Science Review 64(4): 1033–1053.
Slater Tom. 2021. Shaking up the city: Ignorance, inequality and the urban question. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Teschke Benno Gerhard. 2011. “Fatal attraction: A critique of Carl Schmitt’s international political and legal theory”. International Theory 3: 179–227.
Vale Lawrence J. 2014. “The politics of resilient cities: Whose resilience and whose city?”. Building Research and Information 42(2): 191–201.
Wacquant Loïc. 2008. Urban outcasts: A comparative sociology of advanced marginality. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Wacquant Loïc. 2014. “Marginality, ethnicity and penality in the neoliberal city: An analytic cartography”. Ethnic and Racial Studies 37(10): 1687–1711.
Wacquant Loïc. 2022a. “Epistemic bandwagons, speculation, and turnkeys: Some lessons from the tale of the urban ‘underclass’”. Thesis Eleven 173(1): 82–92. https://doi.org/10.1177/07255136221121705.
Wacquant Loïc. 2022b. The invention of the ‘underclass’: A study in the politics of knowledge. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Weber Max. 2004 (1904). „Obiektywność” poznania społeczno-naukowego i społeczno-politycznego. W: tegoż, Racjonalność, władza, odczarowanie, przeł. Marian Holona, 133–194. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Poznańskie.
Wilson William Julius. 1987. The truly disadvantaged: The inner city, the underclass and public policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press (wydanie rozszerzone: 2012).
Wittgenstein Ludwig. 2000. Uwagi różne. Kraków: Wydawnictwo KR.
