Exploring the Boundaries of Second-Person Narrative: The Use of “You” in Maria Gerhardt’s Transfer Window
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26485/ZRL/2022/65.4/2Keywords:
second-person narrative, fictionality, narratology, autobiography, Maria GerhardtAbstract
In Maria Gerhardt’s autobiographical novel, Transfer Window (orig. Transfervindue, 2017), which is set in a fictionalized hospice universe and revolves around Gerhardt’s experience of being a terminal patient, the first-person protagonist, Maria, consistently refers to her partner as “you” without addressing her. This odd pronominal use is typically associated with second-person narrative. Yet, according to most definitions, Transfer Window is not a second-person narrative because of its 1) autobiographical content and 2) first-person protagonist. In this article, I argue that second-person narrative is any narrative in which a “you” is designated, but not addressed, and present a new typology consisting of four different types of second-person narrative: 1) fictional second-person narrative without a marked instance of enunciation, 2) fictional second-person narrative with a marked instance of enunciation, 3) nonfictional second-person narrative without a marked instance of enunciation and 4) nonfictional second-person narrative with a marked instance of enunciation. My approach to second-person narrative is rooted in rhetorical fictionality theory, which provides a framework that allows me to view second-person narration as a narrative technique that, because of its odd pronominal use, signals fictionality, but can occur in both generic fiction and nonfiction. In my analysis of Transfer Window, I dive into Gerhardt’s use of fictionality, both in relation to the setting and the narrative situation of the book.
References
Abbott Porter (2021), The Cambridge Introduction to Narrative, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Auster Paul (2012), Winter Journal, Henry Holt and Company, New York.
Auster Paul (2013), Report from the Interior, Henry Holt and Company, New York.
Bell Alice, Ensslin Astrid (2011), “I know what it was. You know what it was”: Second-Person Narration in Hypertext Fiction, “Narrative” vol. 19, no. 3.
Benveniste (1971), Problems in General Linguistics, trans. E.M. Meek, University of Miami Press, Coral Gables.
Björninen Samuli, Meyer Pernille, Mäkelä Maria, Zetterberg-Nielsen Henrik, eds. (forthco¬ming), Dangers of Narrative and Fictionality, Peter Lang, Bern.
Bonheim Helmut (1983), Conative Solicitude and the Anaphoric Pronoun in the Canadian Short Story [in:] Sprachtheorie und angewandte Linguistik. Festschrift für Alfred Wollmann zum 60. Geburtstag, ed. W. Wolte, Narr, Tübingen.
Booth Wayne ([1961] 1983), The Rhetoric of Fiction, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Buber Martin ([1923] 1937), I and Thou, trans. R.G. Smith, T. and T. Clark, Edinburgh.
Butor Michel ([1957] 1959), A Change of Heart, Simon and Schuster, New York.
Bødker Cecil (1972), Salthandlerskens hus, Gyldendal, København.
Calvino Italo ([1979] 1982), If on a Winter’s Night a Traveler, trans. W. Weaver, Picador, London.
Christensen Pernille Meyer (2020), Hvorfor fortælle dig noget, du allerede ved? Om dufortællinger i dansk litteratur, ”Passage” vol. 35, no. 3.
DelConte Matt (2003), Why You Can’t Speak: Second-Person Narration, Voice, and a New Model for Understanding Narrative, “Style” vol. 37, no. 2.
Fludernik Monika (1993), Second Person Fiction: Narrative You As Addressee And/Or Protago¬nist, “Arbeiten aus Anglistik und Amerikanistik” vol. 18, no. 2.
Fludernik Monika (1994), Introduction: Second-person Narrative and Related Issues, “Style” vol. 28, no. 3.
Genette Gérard ([1983] 1988), Narrative Discourse Revisited, trans. J.E. Lewin, Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
Gerhardt Maria (2014), Der bor Hollywoodstjerner på vejen, People’s Press, København.
Gerhardt Maria ([2017] 2019), Transfer Window, trans. L.F. Van Rooyen, Nordisk Books, Whitstable.
Gammelgaard Lasse R., Iversen Stefan, Jacobsen Louise Brix, Phelan James, Walsh Richard, Zetterberg-Nielsen Henrik, Zetterberg-Nielsen Simona (forthcoming), Fictionality and Litera¬ture. Core Concepts Revisited, The Ohio State University Press, Columbus.
Gjerlevsen Simona Zetterberg, Nielsen Henrik Skov (2020), Distinguishing Fictionality [in:] Exploring Fictionality: Conceptions, Test Cases, Discussions, eds. C.A. Maagaard, D. Schäbler, M.L. Wolff, Syddansk Universitetsforlag, Odense.
Herman David (1994), Textual You and Double Deixis in Edna O’Brien’s A Pagan Place, “Style” vol. 28, no. 3.
Jahn Manfred (2005), Second-Person Narration [in:] Routledge Encyclopedia of Narrative Theory, eds. D. Herman, M. Jahn, M. Ryan, Routledge, London.
Kacandes Irene (1994), Narrative Apostrophe: Reading, Rhetoric, Resistance in Michel Butor’s La Modification and Julio Cortazar’s “Graffiti”, “Style” vol. 28, no. 3.
Lehnert Robert (2012), Autobiography, Memoir and Beyond: Fiction and Non-Fiction in Philip Roth’s The Facts and Paul Auster’s Winter Journal, “De Gruyter” vol. 132, no. 4.
Maagaard Cindie Aaen, Schäbler Daniel, Wolff Marianne Lundholt, eds. (2019), Exploring Fictionality: Conceptions, Test Cases, Discussions, Syddansk Universitetsforlag, Odense.
McHale Brian (1987), Postmodernist Fiction, Methuen, New York and London.
Meyer Pernille (forthcoming), Positioning You: Fictionality and Interpellation in Janne Teller’s War. What if it were here? [in:] Dangers of Narrative and Fictionality, eds. S. Björninen, P. Meyer, M. Mäkelä, H. Zetterberg-Nielsen, Peter Lang, Bern.
Mildorf Jarmila (2013), “Unnatural” narratives? The case of second-person narration [in:] Travelling concepts of narrative, eds. M. Hatavara, L. Hydén, M. Hyvärinen, John Benjamins, Amsterdam.
Mildorf Jarmila (2016), Reconsidering Second-Person Narration and Involvement, “Language and Literature”, vol. 25, no. 2.
Mildorf Jarmila (2019), Autobiography, the Literary, and the Everyday in Paul Auster’s Report from the Interior, “Journal of Literature and the History of Ideas” vol. 17, no. 1.
Newman Daniel Aureliano (2018), Your Body is our Black Box: Narrating in Second-Person Fiction by Edna O’Brien and Jennifer Egan, “De Gruyter” vol. 4, no. 1.
Nielsen Henrik Skov (2011), Fictional Voices? Strange Voices? Unnatural Voices? [in:] Strange Voices in Narrative Fiction, eds. P. K. Hansen, S. Iversen, H. S. Nielsen, R. Reitan, De Gruyter, Berlin.
Nielsen Henrik Skov, Phelan James, Walsh Richard (2015), Ten Theses about Fictionality, “Narrative” vol. 23, no. 1.
Perec George ([1967] 1990), A Man Asleep, trans. A. Leak, Godine, Boston.
Phelan James (2016), Local Fictionality within Global Nonfiction: Roz Chast’s Why Can’t We Talk about Something More Pleasant?, “Enthymema” vol. 16.
Prince Gerald (1987), A Dictionary of Narratology, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln.
Reitan Rolf (2011), Theorizing Second-Person Narratives: A Backwater Project? [in:] Strange Voices in Narrative Fiction, eds. P.K. Hansen, S. Iversen, H.S. Nielsen, R. Reitan, De Gruyter, Berlin.
Rembowska-Pluciennik Magdalena (2018), Second-person narration as a joint action, “Language and Literature” vol. 27, no. 3.
Rembowska-Pluciennik Magdalena (2022), Enactive, Interactive, Social: New Contexts for Reading Second-Person Narration, “Narrative” vol. 30, no. 1.
Richardson Brian (1991), The Poetics and Politics of Second Person Narrative, “Genre” vol. 24.
Richardson Brian (2006), Unnatural Voices: Extreme Narration in Modern and Contemporary Fiction, Ohio State University Press, Columbus.
Schönberger Christina (2017), “You” Reconstructing the Past: Paul Auster’s Winter Journal, “Mnemosyne” vol. 10.
Stanzel Franz ([1979] 1984), A Theory of Narrative, trans. C. Goedsche, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Thorsen Lotte (2017), Maria Gerhardt: Jeg har gjort det smart at være lesbisk, jeg har gjort det smart at være syg. Og nu kan jeg også lige så godt gøre døden smart, “Politiken”, March 4.
Turner Victor ([1969] 1974), The Ritual Process. Structure and Anti-Structure, Penguin Books, London.
Van Gennep Arnold ([1909] 1960), The Rites of Passage, trans. M.B. Vizedom, G.L. Caffee, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Walsh Richard (2007), The Rhetoric of Fictionality, Ohio State University Press, Columbus.
Walsh Richard, Knapp John, Hoover Maxwell, eds. (2020), Fictionality as Rhetoric (“Style”), Penn State University Press, Pennsylvania.
